Boxed mixes have evolved; if you’re like me, you could have two happy memories of them. Growing up, my mother was adept at turning an essential box mix into something amazing.
She understood how to arrange packaged pumpkin bread on a gorgeous holiday dish that appeared homemade or “doctor up” a brownie mix by adding cream cheese to create cheesecake brownies. I now carry that custom into my kitchen, attempting to improve boxed mixes wherever possible.
This year, my preferred is Trader Joe’s Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix. This one is a ride-or-die. Purchasing three boxes right once, I knew this would be a mainstay in my autumn baking calendar. Why? These cookies taste just like they come from a luxury bakery.
The pumpkin in the mix goes rather well with warm spices, including cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, ginger, and cloves. Let’s dissect the reasons behind these cookies’ fall must-have status.
Perfect Combining of Spice and Pumpkin
The way the spices are mixed is very outstanding. They are in harmony. Trader Joe’s Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix achieves the ideal mix, whereas many pumpkin-flavored products overkill the pumpkin or utilize spices sparsely.
It’s not quite pumpkin-flavored, but veers toward the spice-forward side, ideal for a laid-back fall treat. I couldn’t agree more when Reddit users even refer to it as “the best store-bought box cookies.”
These will wow you if you enjoy snickerdoodles, the traditional cinnamon-sugar-coated cookie. One Reddit user called themselves snickerdoodle connoisseurs, sharing their family’s passion for these sweets.
Following the recipe precisely as directed on the box pleased them with how chewy, moist, and tasty the cookies were. Don’t worry if you’re reluctant, as you dislike pumpkins. With just a little pumpkin for that extra fall touch, these cookies are more about the warm, welcoming spices that accentuate the flavor.
Simple to Create, Simple Love
Among its better features is this cookie mix’s simplicity. This is the ideal baking project even on hectic days, as everything fits in one dish. Although the carton advises using an electric hand mixer, honestly, I found it simple to combine by hand with no effort.
Start with a softened stick of butter and an egg; next, stir in the pre-measured dry ingredients from the package. To get the dough together into a soft, sticky consistency, toss a few splashes of milk. No fancy tools are needed.
A cookie scoop (approximately two teaspoons per) makes scooping out the dough balls simple. Here is a tip: Before setting them on a parchment-lined sheet pan, drop the dough ball straight into the cinnamon-sugar coating mixture. This approach simplifies rolling and helps prevent sticky palms. Once they have been coated, the cookies are oven-ready.
The Ideal Baking Time
Although the package directions call for a 12-minute bake at 375°F, many fans including myself have discovered that baking them for the whole time produces rather too crunchy cookies. I advise looking at them at nine minutes, leaving you with cookies with crunchy edges and a soft, chewy interior.
One Reddit member had a similar story, noting that their 12-minute batch was too crunchy. Pulling out the second batch at 9 minutes produced the ideal texture after cooling crispy edges with a soft middle.
The secret is to let them cool on a rack so they will stiffen up without becoming too rigid. Keep a close watch on the timer, as the cookies are mostly cinnamon-covered, and you cannot rely on browning to indicate when they are done.
Experiment with Your Own Twist
Although the traditional recipe is already great, this combination allows plenty of creative possibilities. To make cookie bars rather than individual cookies, I experimented by halving the dough and pushing it into a quarter-sheet tray covered with parchment paper.
I dusted the top with the spice mix and added marshmallows to give the bars a gooey, toasted layer that was a great variation on the classic Snickerdoodle.
I might throw in some chocolate bits next time, following a s’mores-inspired recipe. This flexible blend opens countless opportunities. Toss pecans or walnuts for some crunch; alternatively, sprinkle them with caramel for a sweeter finish.
These Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodles will wow whether you stick with the traditional cookie form or explore bars or other designs.
A Fan Favorite: What Others Have To Say
Not only have I fallen in love with this seasonal delight, but supporters are singing its praises all over the internet. “Delicious. Perfect soft centre and crisp edge.
Not quite pumpkin,” claimed one person who posted a Reddit picture of their cookies. Another said they were dubious but want to stock up before the seasonal item vanishes from Trader Joe’s shelves.
Generally speaking, this combination produces cookies that taste as though they come from an artisanal bakery. Some even noted how well their children performed, which is always encouraging when a boxed mix can satisfy even the most demanding palates.
Available for a Limited Time
Now’s the moment if you haven’t yet gotten a box. Seasonally, Trader Joe’s Pumpkin & Spice Snickledoodle Cookie Mix will not remain in stores for very long.
For just $3.99, you can get a great value on a cookie mix that tastes this excellent. The fact that you could pass these off as handmade is only the cherry on top that is, the sugar on the snickerdoodle in this case.
Conclusion
Anyone who likes quick, mouthwatering delicacies with no work should include Trader Joe’s Pumpkin & Spice Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix in their fall baking lineup.
Whether your goal is to wow friends and family with something delicious or you’re an experienced baker trying to save time, this combination has you covered. It’s the best comfort biscuit for fall, with its balanced spices and trace of pumpkin.
So, the next time you visit Trader Joe’s, grab a three-box container. You won’t regret it.
READ MORE: Costco Recently Added a Beloved Comfort Food, But It’s Starting Problems