Crumbl Cookies has built a dedicated fanbase thanks to its enormous, delicious cookies that change weekly. For many, part of the fun is checking the store, app, or website each Monday to discover the latest flavors.
However, this week, it seems Crumbl is stirring the pot—quite literally—by swapping out cookies for pies in its Thanksgiving lineup. Yes, you heard it right: no cookies for Thanksgiving this year!
What’s on the Thanksgiving Menu?
Crumble is sticking to its Thanksgiving tradition by bringing back its beloved pumpkin pie—but with a twist. Instead of the usual cookie version, it will be served as an actual pie.
This means fans can look forward to enjoying a classic dessert with a fresh take. Alongside the pumpkin pie, the lineup will feature the returning key lime pie and four exciting new recipes:
- Triple Berry Pie: A medley of sweet and tart berries baked into a flaky crust.
- Apple Pie: A traditional favorite, likely filled with spiced apples and a buttery crust.
- Brookie Pie: A delightful combination of brownie and cookie, offering the best of both worlds.
- Cookies and Cream Pie: A creamy dessert that marries the flavors of cookies and cream in pie form.
This lineup represents a significant departure for Crumbl, known for its innovative cookie flavors. Fans are understandably puzzled by the absence of cookies, especially when sweet treats are in high demand.
The Internet Reacts
As news of Crumbl’s pie-centric Thanksgiving lineup leaked, social media erupted with excitement, confusion, and humor. The Reddit post’s title announcing the news perfectly captured the sentiment, asking if Crumbl had “lost their minds” by not offering cookies.
While some fans were eager to try the pies, others questioned the decision, wondering why Crumbl didn’t simply make cookie versions of these classic pies.
One theory floated around the internet suggested that Crumbl might be looking to charge more for the pies, as they have been known to do for more elaborate recipes. Business is business; offering unique desserts could be a strategic move for the brand.
However, not all reactions were adverse. Some fans found the idea of mini pies appealing, especially for those looking to bring desserts to family gatherings. One Redditor remarked, “It’s a cool idea if someone wants to bring mini pies for Thanksgiving dinner with the family.”
Others chimed in, emphasizing the holiday spirit and suggesting that trying something different could be refreshing.
A Mixed Bag of Opinions
The discussion around Crumbl’s Thanksgiving lineup has sparked a lively debate. On one hand, some enthusiasts argue that the pies could bring a new twist to holiday celebrations.
They appreciate the creativity and the chance to experience beloved flavors in a different form. One user even mentioned, “God forbid they do one crazy idea during the holidays!” implying that trying something outside the box could be a welcome change.
On the flip side, some feel a void without the classic cookies. The comment “No pecan pie is crazy” highlights a sentiment that resonates with many the absence of this traditional holiday flavor feels like a missed opportunity.
Pecan pie has long been a staple at Thanksgiving tables, and its exclusion from Crumbl’s offerings leaves some fans disappointed.
What Does This Mean for Crumbl?
Crumbl’s decision to replace cookies with pies for Thanksgiving could signal a shift in its strategy. With the holiday season upon us, the brand may be aiming to capture a broader audience by offering a variety of desserts.
This could appeal to customers looking for more traditional options during family gatherings.
Additionally, the pies may attract customers who have not tried Crumbl’s cookies, expanding the company’s customer base. By diversifying its offerings, Crumbl can cater to different tastes and preferences, enhancing its reputation as a sweet-treat destination.
Conclusion
Crumbl’s Thanksgiving lineup is undoubtedly bold, embracing the season’s spirit while straying from its cookie-centric roots. The introduction of pies offers fans a new way to enjoy familiar flavors, even if it leaves some feeling puzzled or disappointed.
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear: Crumbl is fearless in taking risks and trying new things.
Whether you’re a die-hard cookie fan or open to the idea of pies at Crumbl, the holiday season is shaping up to be interesting. As we approach Thanksgiving, many eagerly anticipate tasting these new offerings.
Will you be among those who give Crumbl’s pies a try, or are you holding out for the return of their iconic cookies? Only time will tell!
READ MORE: Viral Diet Coke With Pickle Juice and Jalapenos