As home cooks, we all know the joy of finding that perfect store-bought treat that could easily pass as homemade. One of the best places to look for such gems is in the premade section of your local grocery store.
For Sam’s Club shoppers, their go-to for parties, potlucks, and holidays often comes from the bakery section. Sam’s Club is a hidden treasure for sweet tooth cravings with an array of mouth-watering breads, pastries, and desserts.
Among all the baked goods, Sam’s Club’s private-label bakery brownies, under the Member’s Mark brand, have garnered a loyal fanbase. People can’t stop raving about their deliciousness; the obsession is real.
These brownies are so sought after that when Sam’s isn’t carrying them, customers are determined to track them down—sometimes even going as far as trying to buy them from the supplier directly. Recently, some savvy Reddit users have uncovered the secret behind these brownies.
The Mystery of the Member’s Mark Brownies
Sam’s Club is known for its Member’s Mark brand, which features a variety of high-quality products, including their famous brownies. The Member’s Mark Gourmet Brownie Platter stands out, offering 24 decadent brownies topped with fudge and a mix of different frostings.
These brownies are typically dressed with cream cheese frosting, caramel, and chocolate icing. Sam’s will often introduce particular varieties, such as fall-themed or patriotic brownies, depending on the season.
What makes these brownies extra unique is their limited availability. They’re usually released during the summer—right in time for graduation parties and backyard barbecues—and remain on sale for about six months. Unfortunately, for brownie lovers, they can be hard to find during the rest of the year.
Many customers swear these are the best store-bought brownies they’ve ever tasted. But what happens when they’re not available? That’s when things get interesting.
The Brand Behind Sam’s Club Brownies Revealed
You’re not alone if you’ve been trying to uncover who makes these “perfect” brownies. And thanks to some detective work from Reddit users, the secret has been revealed: Pillsbury.
Yes, you read that right. According to multiple Reddit threads, Sam’s Club’s Member’s Mark brownies are actually bulk-order Pillsbury brownies.
A Reddit user claiming to work at Sam’s Club shared, “They are bulk order Pillsbury frozen brownies. They come from the distributor, already iced and ready to thaw and serve.” Another user confirmed this by saying, “It says Pillsbury on the box.”
While you won’t find Pillsbury bulk brownies on grocery store shelves, Sam’s Club might sell you a box of these frozen brownies straight from the bakery counter. If you’re lucky, you can snag a box even when the brownie platters aren’t available.
How to Score These Brownies When They’re Out of Season
If the Member’s Mark brownie platter is unavailable, but you’re craving those decadent, fudgy treats, there may be a solution. According to Reddit, some Sam’s Club locations will sell baked goods frozen in bulk, including the brownies.
Many shoppers have reported success purchasing frozen cookies, pies, and muffins directly from the bakery, and the brownies are no exception.
Another interesting detail from Reddit is that these brownies are used in the Brownie Sundae sold year-round at Sam’s Café. So, if you’re in the mood for a sweet treat, you can always swing by the café to get your brownie fix.
If you’re planning a party or special event and need dozens of brownies, ask the Sam’s Club bakery if they have any bulk frozen options. This way, you can enjoy these fan-favorite treats even when they’re not officially on sale.
Too Many Brownies? Try Making Them at Home
If buying brownies in bulk is too expensive, why not make them home? Pillsbury offers a variety of brownie mixes that you can find at most grocery stores. While there’s no way to be sure which specific variety Sam’s Club uses for their Member’s Mark brownies, you can experiment with different Pillsbury mixes to find the one that tastes most similar.
Pillsbury’s Chocolate Fudge, Milk Chocolate, and Dark Chocolate brownie mixes are all great options. Each offers that rich, fudgy texture that Sam’s Club brownies are known for, so you can enjoy a homemade version whenever you like.
Why Sam’s Club Bakery Stands Out
Unsurprisingly, Sam’s Club bakery items, including brownies, have a strong following. The club store is famous for producing high-quality baked goods at affordable prices, making it a go-to destination for sweet treats.
In addition to brownies, Sam’s Club also offers other delicious bakery items like award-winning apple pies, cookie platters, and freshly baked bread.
Many of these items are available year-round, but the seasonal and limited-time offerings, like the brownies, keep customers coming back for more. Whether planning a party, hosting a holiday gathering, or indulging in a sweet treat at home, Sam’s Club Bakery has something for everyone.
Conclusion
If you’re a Sam’s Club bakery brownies fan, now you know the secret behind their irresistible flavor and texture—Pillsbury.
While you can’t buy them directly from Pillsbury, you can still enjoy these delicious brownies by purchasing them at Sam’s Club, either from the bakery section or in frozen bulk.
For those who can’t get enough, remember that these brownies are used in Sam’s Café Brownie Sundae so that you can enjoy them year-round. And if you’re in the mood to bake, Pillsbury’s brownie mixes are an excellent alternative for creating a homemade version of these beloved treats.
Next time you’re at Sam’s Club, remember to check out the bakery and see if those delicious brownies are available. If not, just ask the bakery counter for some frozen options—they might just have the perfect batch waiting for you.
READ MORE: Chick-fil-A Is Making Its Best Secret Menu Item Official