Costco always impresses when it comes to desserts, offering delicious treats that seem to hit the spot all year long. Whether it’s their famous chocolate-covered strawberries in February or their s’mores cookies during summer, there’s always something sweet to satisfy our cravings.
And in the fall, Costco usually shines with its iconic $5 pumpkin pie, a favorite on Thanksgiving tables across the country.
However, this year, Costco has decided to mix things up, introducing a new seasonal dessert that might make you forget all about your pumpkin pie tradition. While pumpkin-flavored treats dominate headlines, Costco’s latest addition to their bakery section is turning heads for all the right reasons.
Let’s introduce you to Costco’s Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake—your new fall obsession.
The Star of Costco’s Fall Dessert Lineup Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake
This season, Costco has launched a new show-stopper in its bakery section, and it’s quickly becoming a fan favorite: the Maple Butter Pecan Bar Layer Cake. It’s not just any cake—this dessert is so mouth-watering that you may wonder if pumpkin pie should step aside.
The Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake is layered to perfection, starting with a fluffy vanilla sponge as the foundation. It’s then topped with a rich maple mousse, adding the sweet autumn flavor we all love. But Costco didn’t stop there—the cake also features a crunchy pecan layer for added texture.
And, just when you think it can’t get any better, the entire creation is crowned with a brown butter mousse topping. Fans of the dessert have described this brown butter mousse as “insane,” and they’re not wrong.
Not Too Sweet, But Just Right
You might think that the cake would be overly sweet with all these layers and flavors, but that’s not the case here. According to early reviews, the cake strikes the perfect balance of sweetness, so you don’t feel overwhelmed after one slice.
Some reviewers are calling it the best cake they’ve ever had.
One fan even raved, “You had me at MAPLE,” highlighting how the subtle yet distinctive maple flavor makes this cake stand out.
Pumpkin pie, while always reliable, can sometimes be predictable. It has a smooth, creamy texture and a flavor profile that doesn’t change much yearly. But Costco’s Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake offers an exciting blend of lightness, crunch, richness, and smoothness in one bite.
The dessert keeps you returning for more, with each bite offering a different flavor experience.
A Beautiful Presentation That Will Wow Your Guests
Not only does the Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake taste amazing, but it’s also visually stunning. The slab-style cake is cleanly sliced to showcase its gorgeous layers—each distinct, from the golden vanilla sponge to the light brown butter mousse.
The final touch is a whipped cream swirling that makes the cake look like it came straight from a high-end bakery.
This dessert is the perfect centerpiece for any fall gathering. Whether you’re hosting a casual tailgate, a Friendsgiving dinner, or the big Thanksgiving feast, this cake will undoubtedly be the star of your dessert spread.
And don’t be surprised if it disappears from the table quickly—one Reddit user even confessed, “I fantasize about devouring a whole one in 10 minutes.” Honestly, we can’t blame them!
Perfect for Any Fall Occasion
This cake isn’t just for the big holidays, either. It’s versatile enough to serve at any fall event, from a cozy weekend get-together to a festive game day tailgate.
No matter the occasion, the Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake will have your guests raving, and you’ll get all the credit for serving such a delicious dessert.
And the best part? You don’t have to slave away in the kitchen to get it. Costco has already done all the hard work, so you must pick one up, slice it, and enjoy it. At $18.99, it’s a bargain for a cake of this caliber.
The Taste Test Why You’ll Love It
So, why is this cake generating so much buzz? It’s all about the taste:
- The vanilla sponge is light and airy, providing the perfect base for the more decadent flavors to come. The maple mousse is sweet but not too sweet, adding a rich, buttery flavor that screams fall.
- There’s the pecan layer, which adds a satisfying crunch to contrast with the smoothness of the mousse.
- The brown butter mousse topping ties everything together, adding a depth of flavor that sets this cake apart from other fall desserts.
Even people who aren’t usually cake fans have been won over by this one. The variety of textures and flavors make every bite an experience, and it’s easy to see why so many people call it their new favorite Costco dessert.
Why You Need to Try It This Fall
Costco’s Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake offers a fresh take on fall flavors. While pumpkin pie will always hold a special place in our hearts, sometimes mixing things up is excellent. This cake brings something new, offering a multi-layered flavor experience that pumpkin pie can’t match.
If you’re a fan of maple, butter, or pecans—or even if you’re looking for something new to try this fall—this cake is a must. Plus, it’s a guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
Whether you’re enjoying it at home with your family or bringing it to a holiday potluck, you can be sure this cake will be a hit.
So, the next time you’re at Costco, don’t hesitate to add the Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake to your cart. It’s available now for $18.99 and is well worth the price for a dessert that’s sure to become a new fall favorite.
Conclusion
We’re not saying you have to abandon your pumpkin pie tradition. After all, there’s room for both desserts on the table. But if you want something to wow your guests and shake up your fall dessert lineup, the Maple Butter Pecan Bar Cake is it.
With its light, rich, and nutty flavors, this cake is everything we want in a fall dessert. So go ahead and treat yourself to a slice (or two). You won’t regret it!
READ MORE: The 16 Recipes We Can’t Wait to Make This October